An Opinion Writing Graphic Organizer That Puts Reasons Before the Draft

Four layouts to draw, with two model topics.

The best opinion writing graphic organizer uses a reasons-first frame: one opinion box, two or three reason boxes with an example under each, and a closing box that restates the opinion. Start with the opinion tree for grades 1 to 3 or any first opinion piece, and move to the reason table once students can write a reason and an example as separate sentences. At Chalkbox, we build free classroom tools and guides for K-12 teachers, and the four layouts on this page are our own designs that you can draw on a board or in a notebook today.

Which Opinion Writing Graphic Organizer to Pick

Pick an opinion writing graphic organizer by two things: the student's grade band and the length of the finished piece. The table below lists the four layouts, the boxes each one holds, and the writer each one suits.

LayoutBoxesBest for
Opinion TreeA trunk for the opinion, three branches for reasons, a leaf on each branch for an example, and roots for the closingGrades 1 to 3 and any student writing a first opinion piece
Reason TableAn opinion row, a table with Reason, Example, and Linking word columns, and a closing rowStudents who can write a reason and an example in separate sentences
Four-Box Paragraph FrameOpinion sentence, reason 1 with example, reason 2 with example, closing sentenceAny grade when the finished product is a single paragraph
Opinion and Counterpoint T-ChartAn opinion line, a reasons column, a counterpoint column, an answer line, and a closing lineGrades 6 to 8 and persuasive pieces that answer the other side

The opinion tree is our starting pick for young writers. Each reason sits on its own branch with its example right above it.

Move a student to the reason table once they write a reason and an example as two separate sentences. Use the four-box frame whenever the assignment is one paragraph, at any grade.

None of these layouts helps a student who cannot yet state an opinion in a full sentence. Work on the opinion statement first with our thesis statement examples, then come back to the organizer, because an organizer does not fix a weak opinion.

Every layout here has an opinion box and reason boxes. The Common Core State Standards grade 3 writing standard W.3.1a asks students to "state an opinion, and create an organizational structure that lists reasons." A reasons-first organizer is that organizational structure, drawn on paper.

What Every Opinion Organizer Needs

Every opinion organizer needs five parts: an opinion, reasons, an example for each reason, linking words, and a closing statement. The grade 3 standard W.3.1 reads "Write opinion pieces on topics or texts, supporting a point of view with reasons." This page quotes only W.3.1 and makes no claim about the standards for other grades.

  • Opinion. One full sentence that says what the student thinks about the topic. W.3.1a asks students to "Introduce the topic or text they are writing about, state an opinion, and create an organizational structure that lists reasons."
  • Reasons. Two or three answers to the question "Why do I think this?" W.3.1b reads "Provide reasons that support the opinion."
  • Examples. One detail under each reason that shows what the reason looks like for this topic. The example box is our editorial addition to the frame. W.3.1c lists "for example" as a linking word, and the example box gives that phrase something to introduce.
  • Linking words. W.3.1c asks students to "Use linking words and phrases (e.g., because, therefore, since, for example) to connect opinion and reasons." Write those four on the board next to the organizer.
  • Closing statement. W.3.1d reads "Provide a concluding statement or section." The closing box restates the opinion in new words so the piece ends where it began.

Before students start filling boxes, check that your drawn frame has a labeled space for all five parts.

Four Opinion Writing Graphic Organizer Layouts to Draw

All four layouts are Chalkbox designs built from plain boxes and lines, so you can draw any of them on a whiteboard, chart paper, or a notebook page. Chalkbox does not have a dedicated graphic organizer generator. Copy the templates below, or print the blank grid from our worksheet templates page and label the boxes by hand.

Opinion Tree

The opinion tree puts the opinion on the trunk, a reason on each branch, an example on each leaf, and the closing statement in the roots. Students fill the trunk first, then the branches and leaves, and finish at the roots.

OPINION TREE

 [Leaf: example] [Leaf: example] [Leaf: example]
 | | |
 [Branch: reason 1] [Branch: reason 2] [Branch: reason 3]
 | | |
 +-------------------+-------------------+
 |
 [TRUNK: My opinion is _______________]
 |
 [ROOTS: Closing sentence that restates my opinion]

Reason Table

The reason table holds the same parts in rows and columns, with a third column that assigns a linking word to each reason. Each row turns into one or two sentences of the draft, so it fits writers who are ready for full sentences.

REASON TABLE

Opinion: I think _______________________________________

+----------------------+------------------------+--------------+
| Reason | Example | Linking word |
+----------------------+------------------------+--------------+
| 1. | | |
+----------------------+------------------------+--------------+
| 2. | | |
+----------------------+------------------------+--------------+
| 3. | | |
+----------------------+------------------------+--------------+

Closing: That is why I think ____________________________

Four-Box Paragraph Frame

The four-box paragraph frame is a paragraph graphic organizer with exactly four boxes: opinion, reason 1 with its example, reason 2 with its example, and closing. Each box becomes one or two sentences, so the frame produces one paragraph. Pair it with our 5-sentence paragraph guide when you want a fixed sentence count.

FOUR-BOX PARAGRAPH FRAME

+-------------------------------+-------------------------------+
| Box 1: Opinion sentence | Box 2: Reason 1 + example |
| | |
| | |
+-------------------------------+-------------------------------+
| Box 3: Reason 2 + example | Box 4: Closing sentence |
| | |
| | |
+-------------------------------+-------------------------------+

Opinion and Counterpoint T-Chart

The opinion and counterpoint T-chart adds the other side to the frame. The left column lists reasons for the opinion, and the right column lists what someone who disagrees might say. A line under the chart holds the student's answer to that counterpoint.

OPINION AND COUNTERPOINT T-CHART

Audience (grades 6-8): _________________________________
My opinion: ____________________________________________

 Reasons for my opinion | What someone who disagrees might say
 ------------------------------+--------------------------------------
 1. | 1.
 2. | 2.
 3. |

My answer to the counterpoint: Some people say ______, but ______.
Closing: _______________________________________________

A Filled-In Example: Should Our Class Have a Longer Recess?

The recess topic below is an invented classroom example written for this page, filled in on the reason table. Use it as a model on the board before students try their own topic.

Opinion: Our class should have a longer recess.

ReasonExampleLinking word
Students focus better after moving.After we run around, it is easier to sit still for math.because
We get more time for games with friends.We could finish a whole game of four square instead of stopping halfway.for example
We practice taking turns.Waiting for the swings means letting everyone have a turn.since

Closing: That is why our class should have a longer recess.

Each row turns into one or two sentences, and the linking word column tells the student how to start the reason or the example. The invented paragraph below is a shorter version of the filled table, using the first two reasons.

Our class should have a longer recess. Students focus better after moving, because sitting still is easier after running around. We would also get more time for games with friends. For example, we could finish a whole game of four square instead of stopping halfway. Therefore, our class should have a longer recess.

The model paragraph uses three of the W.3.1c linking words: because, for example, and therefore. Ask students to underline each one in their own draft and find the organizer box it came from.

A Second Example for the Counterpoint Chart

The home-reading topic below is a second invented classroom example, filled in on the opinion and counterpoint T-chart. It shows how one entry from the right column becomes a single sentence in the draft.

Opinion: Students should read a book at home every night.

Reasons for my opinionWhat someone who disagrees might say
You get to finish stories you started at school.Some nights are busy with sports or chores.
A book at bedtime is a calm way to end the day.Some students would rather choose their own free time.
You can pick books you like.

My answer to the counterpoint: Even a few pages on a busy night still count, and you get to choose the book.

Closing: That is why students should read a book at home every night.

Students pick the counterpoint they think a reader would raise first. Then they join it to their answer with the frame "Some people say ___, but ___." The filled chart above becomes this sentence:

Some people say nights are too busy for reading, but even a few pages before bed still count, and you get to choose the book.

That one sentence goes after the last reason and before the closing. The rest of the piece follows the same order as the recess model: opinion, reasons with examples, then closing.

Adjusting the Organizer by Grade Band

The grade-band advice below is this page's editorial guidance, so adapt it to your class. Only the grade 3 standard is cited on this page, and none of these suggestions comes from a standard.

Primary Grades (K-2)

Use the opinion tree and have students say their opinion aloud to a partner before anything goes on paper. Let students draw a picture on each leaf in place of a written example. A teacher or partner can write the opinion on the trunk while the student dictates it.

Keep the topic close to the classroom, such as recess, a name for a class pet, or a favorite read-aloud. Two branches are enough for a first piece.

Intermediate Grades (3-5)

Ask for a full sentence in every box. Move from the opinion tree to the reason table once a student writes a reason and an example as separate sentences, and fill the linking word column with the four W.3.1c words. Use the four-box paragraph frame for single-paragraph assignments.

Students who freeze at the first sentence can borrow an opener from our opinion sentence starters. Have them copy the starter into the opinion box and finish it in their own words.

Middle School Grades (6-8)

Add a counterpoint with the opinion and counterpoint T-chart. When older students write persuasive pieces, the T-chart works as a persuasive writing graphic organizer once the student names the audience on the top line.

For argument pieces built on evidence, our claim-evidence-reasoning (CER) template gives students a claim, evidence, and reasoning frame. For essays longer than one paragraph, the essay outline generator turns each reason into its own body paragraph.

Teaching Steps from Topic to Draft

Run the same eight-step routine with any of the four layouts, and model every step on the board with the recess topic first.

  1. Choose a topic. Pick a question a student can answer with yes or no, from our writing prompts for kids or from class life.
  2. Say the opinion aloud. Each student tells a partner what they think in one sentence before writing anything.
  3. Fill the opinion box. The student writes that spoken sentence on the trunk, in the opinion row, or in Box 1.
  4. Add reasons. Write two or three answers to "Why do I think this?" with one reason per box.
  5. Add examples. Under each reason, write one detail that shows the reason for this topic.
  6. Assign linking words. Match because, therefore, since, or for example to each reason or example.
  7. Write the closing. Restate the opinion in new words in the closing box.
  8. Draft. Turn each box into one or two sentences, in order, and check off each box as it becomes a sentence.

Common Mistakes with Opinion Organizers

Six mistakes show up on a filled organizer before a student starts drafting, and each one has a fix you can give at the student's desk.

  • An opinion that is a fact. "Our school has recess after lunch" gives nobody anything to disagree with. Ask "Could someone disagree with this?" and have the student rewrite it with should, best, or I think.
  • Reasons that repeat. "Recess is fun" and "We have a good time at recess" are one reason written twice. Cross out the repeat and ask the student a new why question.
  • A reason with no example. An empty example box means the reason has no detail behind it. Point to the box and ask, "What would that look like at our school?"
  • Boxes filled but never drafted. A complete organizer is the plan, and the student still has to write the paragraph. Have the student check off each box as it turns into a sentence.
  • Organizer wording copied word for word. A draft copied straight from the boxes reads like a list. Ask the student to start each reason with a linking word and to restate the opinion in new words in the closing.
  • A weak opinion. "Recess is okay" gives the reasons nothing to support. Send the student to our thesis statement examples to sharpen the opinion before filling any reason box.

Related Chalkbox Resources

For graphic organizers for writing beyond opinion pieces, including the hamburger paragraph, see our guide to other graphic organizers matched to reading and writing tasks. For opinion openers, use the sentence starters page, and for a fixed paragraph shape, use the 5-sentence paragraph guide.

When students compare two choices before picking a side, a Venn diagram template sorts what the two choices share and where they differ. To keep the five parts of an opinion organizer on the classroom wall, build a reference with our anchor charts guide.

For fresh opinion topics, browse the writing prompts for kids collection. For a printable base for any writing graphic organizer, start from the blank grid on worksheet templates.

Bottom Line on Opinion Writing Organizers

Start with the opinion tree for grades 1 to 3 or any first opinion piece. Move to the reason table once students can write a reason and an example in separate sentences, and use the four-box paragraph frame when the product is a single paragraph. This pick rests on the grade 3 standard's wording and our own editorial design; we have not tested these layouts with students or measured outcomes.

If a student cannot yet state an opinion in a full sentence, work on the opinion statement first with the thesis statement examples, because an organizer does not fix a weak opinion. For your next lesson, draw the opinion tree on the board, fill it in together with the recess topic, and leave that opinion writing graphic organizer up while students start their own.

Get the printable pack

Join the Chalkbox list for free printable packs and new tools — no spam, unsubscribe anytime.

Frequently asked questions

What is an opinion writing graphic organizer?

An opinion writing graphic organizer is a drawn frame with labeled boxes for a student's opinion, the reasons behind it, an example for each reason, and a closing statement. Students fill the boxes before they draft. Then they turn each box into one or two sentences. All four layouts on this page can be drawn on a board or in a notebook.

Which graphic organizer is best for opinion writing in 3rd grade?

Use the opinion tree for most third graders, and move to the reason table once a student writes a reason and an example as separate sentences. The reason table has an opinion row, Reason and Example columns, a Linking word column for because, therefore, since, and for example, and a closing row. Those parts line up with the grade 3 writing standard W.3.1.

What is the difference between an opinion and a persuasive writing organizer?

Both use the same frame: an opinion, reasons, examples, and a closing. In our editorial approach, a persuasive writing graphic organizer for older grades adds a named audience and a counterpoint the writer answers. No standard is cited for this difference. The Opinion and Counterpoint T-Chart on this page is the layout for it.

Is there a free printable opinion writing graphic organizer?

Yes, you can copy any of the four layout templates on this page for free and draw them by hand. You can also print the blank grid from our worksheet templates page and label the boxes yourself. Chalkbox does not have a dedicated graphic organizer generator.

What goes in the reason boxes?

Each reason box holds one answer to the question "Why do I think this?" For grades 3 and up, write it as a full sentence. The example for that reason goes in its own box beside or below it. Two reasons that say the same thing in different words count as one, so cross out the repeat and write a new reason.