The NYC School AI Ban Pauses Student-Facing AI in Grades 2-K Through 8
Every flagged product's status and company response from Chalkbeat's reporting, alongside six questions for vetting a classroom AI tool anywhere.
NYC Bans Student-Facing Generative AI in Grades 2-K Through 8
New York City (NYC) public schools paused all software with student-facing generative artificial intelligence (AI) for grades 2-K through 8 in the 2026-27 school year. The city's Department of Education (DOE) flagged 38 products under the rule, and Chalkbeat published the full list: 2 marked banned, 6 marked approved and 30 with no status. Assistive technology, multilingual learners, career-readiness programs and teacher planning are exempt from the NYC school AI ban.
Mayor Zohran Mamdani and Schools Chancellor Kamar Samuels announced the one-year moratorium on September 2, 2026, in a release from the Mayor's Office. It covers "all software that uses student-facing generative AI" and affects about 600,000 students. Companion chatbots are prohibited in all grades.
The release does not define "student-facing generative AI." The department's list of flagged products, in the next section, shows where it has applied the term so far.
The same release limits screen time. Students in 2nd grade and below have restricted one-to-one screen time. For older grades the limits are recommended caps: 30 minutes a day for grades 3 to 5 and 45 minutes a day for grades 6 to 8.
Which Tools NYC Has Flagged
The Education Department flagged 38 products under the moratorium, according to a list Chalkbeat obtained and published on October 23, 2026. Route Fifty republished the article on October 26. Mayor Mamdani has referred to "more than 38" programs, a higher count than the list shows.
The department says its limits apply to student-facing generative AI features and do not necessarily cover a whole product. It reviews products case by case to see whether their AI features can be disabled so the products can be reinstated.
In the version of Chalkbeat's table read on October 29, 2026, 6 rows are marked Approved, 2 are marked Banned and 30 show no status. In 17 rows, the company did not respond to Chalkbeat.
The table and the article text disagree in places. The article says Magma Math turned off its AI hints on September 4 and was cleared on October 5, yet the Magma Math row shows no status and no company response. Chalkbeat may have updated the table since October 29, so look up any tool in Chalkbeat's current table before relying on the status shown here.
The 38 Products Flagged Under the NYC School AI Ban
Rows follow Chalkbeat's order. Statuses appear as printed, and each company response is shortened.
| Tool | Status in Chalkbeat's table | What Chalkbeat reports |
|---|---|---|
| Amira | Banned | Listed as banned. |
| Achieve3000 | Approved | A company spokesperson said it disabled features that violated the policy and received approval to operate in NYC schools. |
| All In Learning | Approved | A company spokesperson said it disabled features that violated the policy and received approval to operate in NYC schools. |
| Avancemos! 1 & 2 (HMH) | No status listed | A company spokesperson said the tool does not use student-facing AI. |
| Brain POP | Approved | A company spokesperson said it disabled features that violated the policy and received approval to operate in NYC schools. |
| Bullseye | No status listed | The company did not respond. |
| Cengage | No status listed | A company spokesperson said the tool does not use student-facing AI. |
| Code.org | No status listed | The company did not respond. |
| CodeHS | Approved | The company says it complies with the city's AI policy and is approved for schools to use. |
| Discovery Education | No status listed | A company spokesperson said the tool does not use student-facing AI. |
| DOE Teaching Assistant | Banned | Listed as banned. |
| Grammarly | No status listed | A spokesperson said schools can "control which AI features are available to their students and staff." |
| Educate (Unlock AI) | No status listed | The company did not respond. |
| Fuel Education | No status listed | The company did not respond. |
| GoGuardian | No status listed | A company spokesperson said the tool does not use student-facing AI. |
| IXL | No status listed | The company did not respond. |
| Great Minds (Eureka Math) | No status listed | A company spokesperson said the tool does not use student-facing AI. |
| HMH Arriba la Lectura! | Approved | A company spokesperson said the tool does not use student-facing AI. |
| Houghton Mifflin (Go Math!) | No status listed | A company spokesperson said the tool does not use student-facing AI. |
| Magma Math | No status listed | The company did not respond. |
| Kahoot | No status listed | The company did not respond. |
| Lexia | No status listed | The company did not respond. |
| Magic School | Approved | The company says it complies with the city's AI policy and is approved for schools to use. |
| Reporteros (Klett) | No status listed | The company did not respond. |
| Newsela | No status listed | The company did not respond. |
| Padlet | No status listed | The company did not respond. |
| Read 180 (HMH) | No status listed | A company spokesperson said the tool does not use student-facing AI. |
| StudySync (McGraw Hill) | No status listed | A spokesperson said the company is reaching out to New York City Public Schools to better understand the issue raised about StudySync. |
| Savvas | No status listed | A company spokesperson said the tool does not use AI. |
| Schoology | No status listed | A spokesperson said the company is "working closely with our New York City Public School customers regarding their data privacy, security and compliance requirements, as we do with all of our customers." |
| Study.com | No status listed | The company did not respond. |
| Wayground | No status listed | The company did not respond. |
| Thinkcera | No status listed | The company did not respond. |
| Turnitin | No status listed | The company did not respond. |
| Vista Higher Learning | No status listed | The company did not respond. |
| Wordly | No status listed | The company said it is not a generative AI tool and should not be banned under the city's AI policy. A spokesperson said it is working with the Education Department to resolve the issue. |
| Yourway Learning | No status listed | The company did not respond. |
| Zoom | No status listed | The company declined to comment. |
Banned Tools Missing from the NYC School AI Ban List
Chalkbeat's article names two more banned tools that are not entries on the list: Coursemojo and Google Gemini. Education Department officials told Chalkbeat Gemini was left off the list because it was already being deactivated for students, though Chalkbeat says it is unclear why that excluded it.
The article also explains the table's two Banned rows. Officials banned Amira, an AI reading tutor used in more than 200 schools, outright because they said it cannot function without AI. The department's own "teaching assistant" chatbot, built with Microsoft and used in six schools last year, was discontinued for students.
One Approved row carries a limit the table does not show. Chalkbeat reports that the department allows HMH Arriba la Lectura only for students learning English.
Why Some Vendors Say They Were Flagged by Mistake
Several companies on the list told Chalkbeat their products do not belong there, and the department has not explained how it decided which tools met its definition. That gap includes cases where a company disputes that its tool uses AI at all.
Chalkbeat reports these company positions:
- Wordly says it does not use generative AI and is working to get off the list.
- HMH says none of its listed products use student-facing AI.
- All In Learning disabled its AI grading elements quickly and says it was already in compliance when the department contacted it.
- Magma Math turned off its AI hints on September 4, and the department cleared it to keep operating on October 5, 31 days later.
Across the table, 8 rows carry a company statement that the tool does not use student-facing AI. Another 3 rows say the company disabled features and received approval, and 2 say the company is in compliance and approved. Chalkbeat quoted critic Leonie Haimson: "You cannot trust the DOE to independently evaluate and assess these products."
A department spokesperson said parents can contact their school or local community education council to learn which technology the school uses.
Who Is Exempt
The release exempts three groups of students from the moratorium:
- Students with disabilities who use assistive technology
- Multilingual learners
- Students in career readiness programs, such as computer science
Chalkbeat describes the multilingual exemption as a carve-out for tools that help English language learners.
Teachers can keep using AI for instructional planning and operational tasks, as long as the tools meet NYC Public Schools safety standards, according to the release. The release does not address AI for grading or counseling. Chalkbeat reports that a teacher-facing AI grading feature in one flagged assessment tool is not allowed under the city's policy. A teacher who wants to use AI for grading or counseling should ask the school first.
The rule applies to New York City public schools, and other districts set their own. If you teach outside New York City and your district blocks a tool you need, you can ask your district to review a blocked tool.
What High Schools Can Use
High school students fall outside the grades 2-K through 8 moratorium, though the companion chatbot ban still applies to them. Every high school student has access to twice-yearly AI literacy classes, and the release describes two 45-minute modules. The modules cover what AI is and is not, bias, risks, ethics and career impacts.
Up to 50,000 general-education students, about 5% of enrollment, can take part in five pilots. Each high school can run at most five pilot classes, and each class needs direct supervision by a trained educator and vetted tools.
| Pilot tool | Subject | Weekly limit |
|---|---|---|
| Quill | English language arts | Up to 15 minutes a week |
| Edia | Math | Up to 20 minutes a week |
| Brisk Teaching and Brisk Boost | Teacher-created activities | 10 to 20 minutes, once or twice a week |
| Playlab | Several subjects | At most two assignments per marking period |
| Intel AI-Ready Schools | Several subjects | One period a week |
The release names Brisk Teaching and Brisk Boost in a single Brisk entry. Playlab's cap is counted per marking period, which makes it the only limit in the table that is not weekly.
How NYC Says It Reviews Tools
NYC Public Schools says every technology tool it uses goes through an "exhaustive review," and tools are barred if their functionality is not "mission-critical to learning." The release lists five review criteria:
- Vendor accountability for safety and transparency
- Ethics
- Evidence of learning design and instructional impact
- Prior research
- Continuous user feedback
A Technology in Schools Coalition will assess the moratorium and the pilots through the 2026-27 school year. Its members are students, educators, parent leaders, elected officials, advocates, union partners and experts. The coalition will then publish a report with recommendations for future school years.
A Checklist for Vetting Classroom AI Tools
Six questions, one for each of the city's five review criteria plus its mission-critical test, let a teacher vet a student-facing AI tool with a vendor or a district tech team. At Chalkbox, we build free classroom tools and guides, and we wrote these questions from our own reading of the city's criteria. They are not a New York City document, and we have not tested any tool on Chalkbeat's list.
- Accountability: Who at the company answers for student safety, and what does the company publish about how its AI feature works?
- Ethics: What will the company do, and refuse to do, with the work and data students produce in the tool?
- Evidence of impact: What evidence shows the AI feature was designed for learning and changes how students learn?
- Prior research: Which earlier studies does the company point to, and did those studies look at the AI feature or another part of the product?
- User feedback: How do teachers and students report a problem with the AI feature, and who at the company reads those reports?
- Mission-critical use: Does the lesson need the AI feature, and can a school turn that feature off while keeping the rest of the tool?
We wrote question 6 with the department's case-by-case reviews in mind. Three approved products and Magma Math received approval to operate after their companies turned off AI features. Send these six questions to the vendor or your district tech team before you assign any student-facing AI tool.
What This Means for Teachers
For a teacher in New York City, the city's release and Chalkbeat's reporting support one plan for the 2026-27 school year. Plan lessons with AI if you wish, and keep student-facing generative AI away from students in grades 2-K through 8. Because the department rules on AI features one product at a time, ask your school before relying on any tool whose AI feature students touch.
Outside New York City, districts set their own rules, and the city's six review criteria make a usable set of questions for a vendor or a district tech team. Chalkbox's guide to writing an AI policy for schools covers the reporting on teacher grading limits.
Three updates would change this advice in New York City: the department reinstating more tools after vendors turn off AI features, a newer version of Chalkbeat's table, or the coalition's report. Before your next lesson, look up each tool you plan to use with students in Chalkbeat's table of products flagged under the NYC school AI ban.
Join the Chalkbox list for free printable packs and new tools — no spam, unsubscribe anytime.
Frequently asked questions
Does the NYC AI ban apply to high school students?
Only in part. The one-year moratorium on student-facing generative AI covers grades 2-K through 8, but the ban on companion chatbots applies in all grades. Every high school student has access to twice-yearly AI literacy classes, and up to 50,000 general-education students can join five pilots that use vetted tools under a trained educator's direct supervision.
Is Google Gemini banned in NYC schools?
Yes. Chalkbeat reports that Google Gemini is banned for students and was already being deactivated for them. Gemini is not an entry on the 38-product list. Education Department officials told Chalkbeat it was left off because it was already being deactivated for students, though Chalkbeat says it is unclear why that excluded it.
Can NYC teachers use AI to plan lessons?
Yes. The Mayor's Office release says teachers may keep using AI for instructional planning and operational tasks, as long as the tools meet NYC Public Schools safety standards. The release does not address AI for grading or counseling, so ask your school before using AI for either.
Why was my ed-tech tool flagged in the NYC AI ban?
The Education Department has not explained how it decided which tools met its definition of student-facing generative AI, according to Chalkbeat. The department says its limits apply to AI features and reviews products case by case to see whether those features can be disabled and the product reinstated. Magma Math, for example, turned off its AI hints on September 4 and was cleared to keep operating on October 5.
Does the NYC school AI ban apply outside New York City?
No. The rule covers New York City public schools, and other districts set their own rules on AI tools. Teachers elsewhere can still use the city's published review criteria as questions for a vendor or a district tech team.
This page summarizes New York City statements and press reporting for educators. Product statuses change; confirm a tool's current status with your school and the vendor.