A Blank Rubric Template You Can Copy and Fill In

A blank rubric grid to copy, plus how to write each level.

To make a blank rubric template, copy a grid with your criteria down the side and four performance levels across the top. Then write each cell as an observable description of the work at that level. At Chalkbox, we build free classroom tools and guides for teachers, and the grid below is a plain table you can paste into any document or copy onto paper.

A rubric is a scoring guide. It lists the criteria a piece of work will be judged on and describes what the work looks like at each performance level.

A Blank Rubric Template You Can Copy

The blank rubric template below has four criteria rows, four performance levels and a score column, for a maximum of 16 points.

Criteria4 Exceeds3 Meets2 Approaching1 BeginningScore
Criterion 1: [name][describe][describe][describe][describe]__ / 4
Criterion 2: [name][describe][describe][describe][describe]__ / 4
Criterion 3: [name][describe][describe][describe][describe]__ / 4
Criterion 4: [name][describe][describe][describe][describe]__ / 4

Total: __ / 16

Fill it in with these four moves:

  1. Name each criterion. Replace each [name] with one thing the task asks for, such as main idea or evidence.
  2. Describe each level. Fill each [describe] cell with something a reader could point to in work at that level.
  3. Rename the levels if needed. If your school uses its own scale, swap in its level names and keep the 4-to-1 numbers.
  4. Score and add. Score each row out of 4, then add the four rows for a total out of 16.

If you would rather have a rubric drafted from your assignment than write every cell yourself, use the Chalkbox rubric generator and edit what it gives you.

Choosing a Rubric Format before You Fill It In

The grid above is an analytic rubric, which scores each criterion separately. Two other common formats use a different layout.

FormatHow it scoresPick it when
AnalyticScores each criterion separately in a gridStudents need to see which part of the work to improve
HolisticOne overall score from a single description per levelA quick overall judgment is enough
Single-pointOne column describing the target (Meets), with space beside it for notes on what falls short or goes beyondThe feedback is the goal

These are three common formats, and the names do not come from an official classification.

To make a single-point version, keep the Criteria and 3 Meets columns and replace the other level columns with two note columns. To make a holistic version, write one description per level for the whole piece of work instead of one per criterion.

How to Write Each Descriptor in a Blank Rubric Template

A descriptor is the text in one cell of the grid, and each one should name something a reader could point to in the student's work. Write them in this order:

  1. Choose three to five criteria. Each one should match something the task asks for. A paragraph about a book asks for a main idea and evidence, so those become rows.
  2. Write the Meets description first. Use observable terms, meaning what a reader could point to in the work. The Meets column is the target, and the other levels are built from it.
  3. Write the levels on either side by changing one thing at a time. Change how many, how accurate or how complete, and keep the rest of the sentence the same.
  4. Use the same wording pattern across a row. When every cell in a row follows one pattern, the levels are comparable at a glance.
  5. Replace vague words. "Good", "nice" and "poor" need to say what makes the work so, such as "uses two specific details".
  6. Test the grid on real work. Before you hand it out, read one real piece of student work against the rubric. Revise any cell you could not apply to that work.

In the Evidence row of the example below, Meets is "Uses two specific details". Exceeds raises the count to three or more, Approaching drops to one detail or general details, and Beginning has no details from the text. Only the number and specificity of details change from cell to cell.

An Invented Example of a Filled Grade 5 Rubric

The filled rubric below is an invented example for teaching, written for a grade 5 paragraph about a book.

Criteria4 Exceeds3 Meets2 Approaching1 Beginning
Main ideaStates a clear main idea and links every detail to itStates a clear main idea; most details link to itMain idea is present but unclear; some details do not linkNo main idea
EvidenceUses three or more specific details from the textUses two specific detailsUses one detail or details are generalNo details from the text
OrganizationBeginning, middle and end with transition wordsBeginning, middle and endSome order, missing a partNo clear order
ConventionsAlmost no errors in capitals, punctuation or spellingA few errors that do not block meaningErrors sometimes block meaningErrors often block meaning

Read it row by row and you can see the descriptor steps at work:

  • Main idea changes how many details link to the main idea, from every detail to most to some that do not link.
  • Organization adds one thing at the top level: Meets has a beginning, middle and end, and Exceeds adds transition words.
  • Conventions sits in its own row, so spelling and punctuation are scored apart from content.
  • Every row keeps one wording pattern, so a student can find the single change between two cells.

From Rubric Points to a Percent

Four criteria scored on a 4-point scale give a maximum of 16 points, so each point is worth 6.25 percentage points of the total (100 divided by 16).

In our worked calculation on the example above, we scored an invented student 4 on main idea, 3 on evidence, 3 on organization and 2 on conventions. That adds to 12 of 16, which is 75%. A second invented student scoring 4, 4, 3 and 3 has 14 of 16, which is 87.5%.

One level on one criterion moves the percentage by 6.25 points. The full range on a 16-point rubric looks like this:

Total pointsPercent of 16
16100%
1593.75%
1487.5%
1381.25%
1275%
1168.75%
1062.5%
956.25%
850%
743.75%
637.5%
531.25%
425%

The lowest possible total is 4, because the lowest level on each row is 1. A student at Beginning on all four criteria still shows 25% on this table.

This page does not set a grade scale. Many schools do not equate a 3 to a B, or 75% to any particular letter grade. Convert the percent with your school's or district's grading policy.

Weighting One Criterion

If one criterion matters more, multiply its score and raise the maximum to match. Weights are your decision.

In our worked calculation, we weighted evidence by 2 on the same four-criterion rubric. The first invented student scored main idea 4, evidence 3, organization 3 and conventions 2. With evidence doubled, the total is 4 + (3 x 2) + 3 + 2 = 15. The new maximum is 4 + 8 + 4 + 4 = 20, and 15 of 20 is 75%.

That student's percent did not move, because a 3 of 4 on evidence is already 75%. The second invented student shows the shift. Scores of 4, 4, 3 and 3 with evidence doubled give 4 + 8 + 3 + 3 = 18 of 20, which is 90%, up from 87.5%.

On the weighted rubric, each evidence level is worth 10 percentage points (2 of 20 points). Each level on the other three criteria is worth 5 points (1 of 20).

Sharing the Rubric with Students

Treat these as suggestions and pick the ones that fit your class:

  • Hand it out with the assignment. Give students the rubric on the day you assign the work, before they write anything.
  • Have students underline the Meets column. Ask them to underline the words in that column before they start.
  • Use it as a self-check. Students score their own work against the same rubric before turning it in.
  • Keep the filled rubric as the feedback. Hand back a copy of the filled rubric with the work.

Common Blank Rubric Template Mistakes and Fixes

Six common mistakes show up in rubrics, and each one has a direct fix:

  • Too many criteria. More than five criteria makes scoring slow. Cut back to three to five rows that match what the task asks for.
  • Descriptors that only change adjectives. "Good organization" and "great organization" name no observable difference. Change one observable thing instead, such as how many, how accurate or how complete.
  • Levels that skip an observable difference. Read each pair of neighboring cells and name the one thing that changes. If you cannot name it, rewrite the lower cell.
  • Spelling and content scored in one cell. Give conventions their own row, as the example above does.
  • A rubric the students never see. Hand it out when you assign the work.
  • Changing the scale mid-year. Pick the levels once and keep them for every assignment.

Related Chalkbox Resources for Rubrics

For a rubric built around team work, see our group project rubric guide. For claim, evidence and reasoning writing, use the CER rubric. To pair a rubric with quick checks during a unit, try the exit ticket generator.

Bottom Line on Building a Blank Rubric Template

Start with four criteria and four levels, write the Meets column first, and test the grid on one real piece of student work before you hand it out. That advice rests on our worked arithmetic on an invented example, and we have not run it in a classroom.

Your school's grading scale and the task in front of you decide the final levels and weights, so rename or reweight the grid when either one differs. Copy the blank rubric template above into a document, name your four criteria, and write the Meets cell for each row today.

Get the printable pack

Join the Chalkbox list for free printable packs and new tools — no spam, unsubscribe anytime.

Frequently asked questions

How do I make a rubric template?

Draw a grid with three to five criteria down the side and four performance levels across the top, such as 4 Exceeds, 3 Meets, 2 Approaching and 1 Beginning. Write the Meets cell in each row first, using observable terms. Then write the other levels by changing one thing at a time, such as how many or how complete. Test the grid on one real piece of student work before you hand it out.

What is the difference between an analytic and a holistic rubric?

An analytic rubric scores each criterion separately, and a holistic rubric gives one overall score from a single description per level. Use analytic when students need to see which part to improve. Use holistic when a quick overall judgment is enough. A third common format, the single-point rubric, describes only the target level and leaves space for notes.

How many criteria should a rubric have?

A rubric should have three to five criteria that match what the task asks for. More than five criteria makes scoring slow. The blank template above uses four, which gives a maximum of 16 points on a 4-point scale.

How do I turn rubric points into a grade?

Add the criterion scores and divide by the maximum. A student scoring 4, 3, 3 and 2 on a four-criterion, 4-point rubric has 12 of 16, which is 75%. To weight a criterion, multiply its score and raise the maximum to match. Convert the percent to a letter grade with your school's or district's grading policy; this page does not set a grade scale.

Should students see the rubric before they start?

Yes, give students the rubric on the day you assign the work, before they write anything. Ask them to underline the words in the Meets column, and have them use the same rubric as a self-check before they turn work in. A rubric the students never see is one of the common mistakes to avoid.